We who with songs beguile your pilgrimage / And swear that Beauty lives though lilies die, / We Poets of the proud old lineage / Who sing to find your hearts, we know not why ... (James Elroy Flecker)

16.4.26

If Life is Meaningless, Why Bother?

 

‘Has life a meaning?’ I posed 

as a theoretical question, once, 

to a couple I knew.


‘Has life a meaning,’ 

she returned, ‘– for whom?’

‘Exactly!’ said he.


I dismissed them in my mind

for poor understanding. 

I was 24.


Now, at 86, I maintain 

it doesn’t matter if life seems – 

or is – without meaning. 


Why bother? Because I happened: 

I have a life. Because I wish to enjoy, 

to savour this (arguably random) gift. 


Because I wish that

it count for something.

If only to me. 


Because, whatever it may or may not 

mean in the grand scheme 

(if there is one), 


I may give it whatever 

personal meaning I choose. And

I do so choose.




Written  for Poets and Storytellers United at Friday Writings #223: Why Bother?  (Also, a poet I admired once told me, 'Philosophy is death to poetry.'  This is an attempt to show that they can sometimes combine with no detriment to either – though, some readers may think that I have produced neither!)






22 comments:

  1. I think I was in my 40s when I realised life was meaningless and since then have been trying to give it meaning, instead of following the hedonistic why bother, route. Funny how that works.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. HAa I was also in my forties when I reached this point.

      Delete
  2. What a wonderful attitude to why we are here - as long as we finding a meaning for ourselves and a sense of worth to be in this world then that is what counts - Jae

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I believe it's what puts the aliveness into a life.

      Delete
  3. The meaning of life is to live. You are doing it perfectly.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, beautifully summed up! I do agree that that is the meaning. (So I guess we're all doing it perfectly, really.)

      Delete
  4. It is about base survival on the primal scale yet sometimes it seems we are failing. Otherwise, meaning is what we make it.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Agreed.

      The truth is, we don't know, and most of us won't ever know, if we are indeed failing and will continue to make collective choices which ensure that. I guess we just have to keep trying as hard as we can while we're here, both on a planetary and a personal level.

      Delete
  5. "...Because I happened:

    I have a life. Because I wish to enjoy,

    to savour this (arguably random) gift."....PERFECT. I love the attitude of the speaker.
    And thank you so much Rosemary for your kind comment on my blog.


    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And thank you, Sumana, for this kind comment on mine.

      Delete
  6. It like asking are miracles world. I one way it is a miracle that we are even here. I think the meaning is to learn to be yourself truly and that helps everyone.

    ReplyDelete
  7. If life had no meaning and we all (writers & poets among others) are assigning meaning to it, then probably this is what it ought to be.
    We have to give a meaning, Justify the millions of sperms and eggs that didn't make it...
    It makes a difference ...

    ReplyDelete
  8. i used to be
    confidently certain
    about most things
    now
    i know nothing
    (I think:)

    Rall

    ReplyDelete
  9. Inspiring and well written "And I do so choose." Good I second that

    ReplyDelete
  10. "Because I wish that it count for something. If only to me." Living our lives with this philosophy is truly the answer, I've always believed it. I already knew that YOU did as well.

    ReplyDelete

DON'T PANIC IF YOUR COMMENTS DON'T POST IMMEDIATELY. They are awaiting moderation. Please allow for possible time difference; I am in Australia. ALSO, IF YOU ARE FORCED TO COMMENT ANONYMOUSLY – do add your name at the end, so I know it's you!