We who with songs beguile your pilgrimage / And swear that Beauty lives though lilies die, / We Poets of the proud old lineage / Who sing to find your hearts, we know not why ... (James Elroy Flecker)

5.4.24

Would I Rather Be a Woman or a Fish?


5 April 2024:
NaPoWriMo prompt: 
Today we’d like you to start by taking a look at Alicia Ostriker’s poem, “The Blessing of the Old Woman, the Tulip, and the Dog.” Now try your hand at writing your own poem about how a pair or trio of very different things would perceive of a blessing or, alternatively, how these very different things would think of something else (luck, grief, happiness, etc).


Remembering that I set myself to explore form this year, I decided to try it as a Rondel – perhaps not one of my better ideas. (But do go and read the prompt poem, which is lovely!)


‘To be exactly where I want –

to be here now, to be human –

how blessed I am!’ said the woman

in the posh seafood restaurant.


The population’s getting scant

for certain fish in the ocean.

To be exactly where you want,

here, now – is that only for humans?


For fish, what blessing does life grant?

Just that – the life that they’re given.

They need no other heaven

than to live as long as they’re meant,

to be exactly where they want.



21 June '24:
Sharing with Poets and Storytellers United, for Friday Writings #132: An Elegant Sufficiency. Having an insufficiency of time this week, I looked for an old piece of mine which I hadn't yet shared. This seems to be the only one I have which comes anywhere near the idea. (
It's my own prompt at P&SU, yet I now realise that my life is characterised more by gusto and greed!)  





26 comments:

  1. And so they are and we are, completely ourselves😊

    ReplyDelete
  2. Now I've read the prompt poem and so many interesting variations today, am tempted to try it in with of my next few prompts... !!!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I'm not thrilled with what I did, but it sure is an interesting prompt, allowing for lots of possibilities.

      Delete
    2. Oh I remember this one... and I did try it during Glopowrimo!!! It does allow for lots of possibilities!!! https://thotpurge.wordpress.com/2024/04/09/humanity/

      Delete
  3. You remind us that is good to be human - to appreciate what we have now - happy solstice to you - Jae

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks, Jae. I hope your Solstice is warmer than mine here!

      Delete
  4. Lovely poem. A Woman, on balance.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Wise thoughts. I'm glad to be just me.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. And how eloquently you said so, in the poem you shared with us this week!

      Delete
  6. Every creature has its own point of view but to contemplate existence and then weave these thoughts into poetic prose is exquisitely human. :)

    ReplyDelete
  7. I like this poem, and it's form. I'll have to go look up the Rondel form.
    ..

    ReplyDelete
  8. Oh, how you weave the poem so elegantly. There seems to be three points of view.
    A rondel, I find it very challenging. :)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Oh thank you! That compliment means a lot coming from such a master craftsman as yourself. (I am surprised you find the rondel challenging.) Yes, perceived point of view of fish and human, plus overall view of 'omniscient author.'

      Delete
  9. Yes, it is elegantly sufficient; it is better to be where we are and do what we want. Nice idea Rosemary.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Definitely human! NIce to take time to appreciate being human now and then.

    PK

    ReplyDelete
  11. This is lovely Rosemary. I think you mastered the form quite well.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you so much! All the favourable comments on this one have been most reassuring, and encourage me to suppose it might be better than I'd thought.

      Delete

DON'T PANIC IF YOUR COMMENTS DON'T POST IMMEDIATELY. They are awaiting moderation. Please allow for possible time difference; I am in Australia. ALSO, IF YOU ARE FORCED TO COMMENT ANONYMOUSLY – do add your name at the end, so I know it's you!